I had thought that I arrived in New York too late to participate in Restaurant Week. Then, flipping through an issue of TimeOut New York, I came across a two page ad spread telling me that no, I wasn't too late, that 85 restaurants were continuing their promotions through Labor Day. There is a god.
When I read Shar the list of participating restaurants at which we can get $35 prix fixe dinners, I heard a gasp from her end of the phone. "Manhattan Ocean Club. Oh my god," she exclaimed. "The last time we went, the five of us racked up a $900 bill. Not including tip." She paused. "We're going!"
I did some quick research on the chef. Craig Koketsu was a Bay area native who helped Jeremiah Tower open the renowned Stars in Palo Alto. After, he moved to New York because of the belief that living here was "crucial" for a training chef. (Sounds familiar.) He became chef de partie at Lespinasse, then sous chef. After the restaurant closed, he was hired as executive chef at Manhattan Ocean Club, where he developed a menu of incredibly fresh seafood entrees with hints of Asian influence.
Reserving a table at Manhattan Ocean Club for a Friday night was simple, since it's not one of the trendy restaurants that are all over the NYC newspapers and magazines, because of its celebrity chef or new take on new cuisine. Rather, it falls in the category of restaurants that produces consistent, reliable food, akin to Gramercy Tavern but without the legendary prestige.
With all the menu options, half of us decided to forgo the prix fixe. Either way, the meal was a worthwhile one.
The appetizers were surely a great start. Despite the name of the restaurant, the house clam chowder bares no resemblence to standard Manhattan clam chowder, which, to a Massachusetts native, is just a thin broth with totato soup. This is thick, hearty, New England clam chowder that made the Bostonian in me smile widely. The crab cakes were large, succulent, and perfectly crisp on the outside. Other options included spicy sake steamed mussels, and hamachi (yellowtail) sashimi with green papaya.
For the main courses, there is the option of daily fresh fish cooked a la plancha. Norwegian salmon, yellow fin tuna, halibut, grouper, pink snapper, diver scallops, black sea bass, or Guatamalan shrimp. Any of those can be cooked with sauce vierge, chili garlic sauce, 5 herb aioli, ginger scallion hollandaise, pineapple tamarind, lemon soy brown butter, spicy lime and cucumber vinaigrette, or extra-virgin olive oil with balsamic, fig, or banyuls vinegar? My yellow fin tuna in sauce vierge (basically a light tomato sauce with lemon juice, evoo, and capers) was cooked with well, with the light sauce allowing the freshness of the fish to shine through. The spicy garlic sauce, when cooked with salmon, was great, but could be too heavy if paired with any of the lighter fish. There are also seafood options that aren't a la plancha, including dover sole and lobster roll. For the landlubbers, there are lamb chops, roast chicken breast, and filet mignon, but then again, to me, it is a cardinal sin to order anything but seafood in a seafood restaurant.
Side dishes are served family style. Sauteed spinach seemed a bit oily for my taste, but jumbo sticks of potato croquettes are as crisp as the crab cakes and more than filling.
Looking around the restaurant, the whole lobster appears to be one of the most popular menu options. The soaring seafood tower appetizer, filled with lobster, shrimp, mussels, clams, and everything else you could possibly want, is a show stopper. It should be, as a $150 appetizer.
On the sweeter side of things, desserts were a mixed bag. One of the options was a large plate of cookies served with vanilla ice cream, which would be good if you were a ten-year-old child with a fondness of milk chocolate. The chocolate and peanut butter tart was so hard that one had a hard time poking the fork through, and an equally hard time chewing. There was a blueberry cobbler that was overly sweet. But those aforementioned desserts were massive servings, and when all were served at once, made my tiny lemon chiffon cake look like a weakling among giants. I received a few "haha, guess you picked the wrong dessert," comments. Well, while everyone else was prodding their hulking masses of sugar, I was savoring the delicate balance between sweet and tart in mine, and finished every last bit.
It was a delicious evening, and thanks to the blessed Restaurant Week on-goings, the bill came nowhere close to $900.
Manhattan Ocean Club - 57 W. 58th St., Midtown West